Welcome to The Fake Intellectual, a thoughtfully curated online journal of essays, reflections, and curiosities. Here you’ll find a quiet space for considered thoughts, shared interests, and meaningful distractions. Settle in and enjoy the slow pleasure of reading, published twice a year.

Subscribe to our newsletter to be the first to know when each issue is released and receive a bonus article curated just for subscribers.

We don't do social media, but if we did, we would follow our Editor Thomas W Coombs over on Instagram, expect wine, food and photography.

Issue 50; The Morning Read Book Review

In this section, I share my thoughts on the books I’ve been reading over coffee and breakfast.  For this issue, I brushed up on my wine adventure, with 
Who’s Afraid of Romanée-Conti? by Dan Keeling and hit up my History prowess with Sapiens by Yuval Noah Harari.


I always believed I had a solid grasp of human history, from our earliest beginnings to the societies we inhabit today. I’ve long been fascinated by human behaviour: the complexity of our choices, as well as the recurring patterns we seem unable to break. Reading
Sapiens challenged that belief and opened my eyes to just how deeply rooted many of these behaviours are, stretching back to our first steps on Earth and our early encounters with rival species.
The book is really split into two parts. The first half is a captivating exploration of human origins. It traces the history of Homo Sapiens, our interactions with Neanderthals and other human species, and the theories about how we lived and spread across the globe. The material is presented clearly, making it accessible even if you’re not a scientist. You can follow the story of how we evolved, migrated, and even interbred. While some of the science has since advanced, the book remains an engaging introduction to our natural history, and a sobering reminder of how destructive we’ve always been, both to one another and to the world around us.
The second half shifts focus to more recent history and speculative ideas about the future. Here, the book loses some of its strength. Instead of building on the careful research of the first half, it drifts into the author’s own theories, sometimes feeling more like self-help musings than grounded science. New terms and concepts are introduced without much support, and the rigor of the early chapters gives way to looser speculation. While some of the ideas are thought-provoking, they don’t carry the same weight as the historical sections. At times, it feels as though these chapters were written to bulk out the book rather than extend its insights.

Overall, Sapiens is still well worth reading, especially for the first half. Just be prepared: the final sections require more patience, and they may leave you wishing the author had stayed closer to established science.

Breakfast wine, anyone? Don’t worry I mean reading about it, not drinking it. As a wine lover, I was eager to dive into the latest book by writer, restaurateur, and wine importer Dan Keeling.
Who’s Afraid of Romanée-Conti? explores an approachable way to enjoy great wines. Styled much like Noble Rot, the magazine Keeling is known for, the book unfolds as a collection of articles in which he visits wineries across both famous and lesser-known winemaking regions. Each section, once you navigate the French names and terminology, offers recommendations on what to drink, from which wineries, and at what price point, ranging from “affordable” to eye-wateringly expensive.
The premise is appealing, but some articles fall flat. A few are so densely packed with obscure French places and château names that even with my decent wine knowledge, I occasionally lost the thread. There are also plenty of name-drops of people the author assumes we should know, but for many readers, they’ll mean little.
As the book progresses, the articles tend to get shorter, with the occasional longer piece mixed in. Still, the repetition makes them start to blend together, and by the end, the initial charm feels a little worn.
Taken as a whole, though, the book feels exactly like what it aims to be: a magazine in book form, complete with both hits and misses. It’s fun, informative, and very well written. And for wine enthusiasts, it’s worth picking up. Beyond its content, it’s also a handsome object: a large-format hardback with a ribbon bookmark that looks just as impressive on a coffee table as it does on a bookshelf, a fine addition to any wine lover’s library.
Main Article Photo by Rhamely on Unsplash